Wednesday, November 05, 2008

Elitism: A Myth?

“If you don’t include your women graduates in your breeding pool and leave them on the shelf, you would end up a more stupid society. So what happens?"

“There will be fewer bright people to support dumb people in the next generation. That’s a problem.”

-From National Day Rally 1983




“We must encourage those who earn less than $200 per month and cannot afford to nurture and educate many children never to have more than two (children),”

“We will regret the time lost if we do not now take the first tentative steps towards correcting a trend which can leave our society with a large number of the physically, intellectually and culturally anaemic.”

-From National Day Rally 1967



Source: http://www.singapore-window.org//sw08/081101ST.HTM




The above quotes are the best I could find. Apparently transcripts from such old National Day Rallies don't exist, since it was behind closed doors, not broadcasted, like how it is currently.

Obviously, the issue of the 'stop-at-two' policy is secondary here. The major point is that our MM Lee meant the birth control policies only for the non-graduates, which he so gracefully termed 'dumb people'. It's grossly reminiscent of something that fits into George Orwell's Animal Farm.

Such courses of actions are an anathema to what Singapore really is about: Meritocracy.

Our leeders have always insisted that Singapore rewards the best of the best, cream of the crop, top of the line. In a way, what MM Lee proposed is to distort the values of meritocracy.

By insisting that the best are offsprings of the best, meritocracy becomes a twisted version of monarchy and nepotism, since the best will inherit the best.

However, a perfect slap to MM Lee's face was when his grandson was born a slightly autistic albino. The child's mother, Wong Ming Yang, allegedly died of heart attack, and the husband, current PM Lee, remarried to current Temasek Holdings CEO Ho Ching. That's the official version.

The word on the street (however untrue it may be) is that Wong Ming Yang committed suicide because MM Lee was unhappy that she gave birth to a son that was obviously not going to be 'the best', and made PM Lee remarry a fast-rising civil servant for power.

Obviously that was a bit of a far-fetched theory, but had it been in a media circus of a place like Taiwan or Hollywood, the investigative journalism may reveal more than meets the eye.

But what is definitely the factual is the elitism that still exists today.

A few good examples would be from a couple of Ang Mo Kio GRC representatives that are strangely similiar.

Comparing both the Wee Shu Min and Li Hongyi public fracas, we can find lots of eery likeness.



Both are children of big shot politicians (one Wee Siew Kim, one PM Lee Hsien Loong)

Both went to the supposedly 'elite' RJC.

One condemned a 'commoner' for crying out about how tough life is, the other bypassed all chains of command, even emailing the Minister of Defence (thanks to Dad's conatcts) just to complain about a CO.

Both got away with a slap on the wrist. Wee Shu Min's father only reprimanded her. Her only loss was to close down her blog. Li Hongyi was "formally charged and administered a reprimand after a summary trial", even though in other states what he did tantamounted to a court-martial case that would have gotten him fired.

Both parents kept decidedly mum about the entire business. Wee Siew Kim later released a statement condoning his daughter's actions and even praised her, saying "As a parent, I may not have inculcated the appropriate level of sensitivity, but she has learnt a lesson, and it's good that she has learnt it at such an early stage in life.'"

And lastly, both Wee Siew Kim & PM Lee's political career won't be affected by their children's action.

Imagine if Sarah Palin's son in Iraq emailed US Defense Secretary Robert Gates over an officer only getting 10 extra duties for punishment. Palin's political career would be as dead as Achmed.


Another issue is the usage of the term 'graduates' as an equivalent to 'bright people' (see quotes from National Day Rally 1983, where female graduates were used as an equivalent to bright people).

This is a stereotype that has gone on until today, where degree almost equates you with cleverness, which is certainly not true. Granted, a lot of them really are clever, but they aren't smart.

They're just servants entrapped into the system, capable of rote learning, but unable to think for themselves or be creative. Much like a human robot.

Personally, I feel that this is nonsensical. A person's future career can only be justified through a degree. Just this slip of paper can give a much higher pay. What if someone who's really smart, but didn't want to waste his money and years of his life getting buried in books in university?

Would that person be less talented than a degree holder? Certainly so, in the current society, where I've seen and heard many such similiar cases when the smarter, more capable person was not accepted, with a degree holder chosen in favour.

Well, having society filled with the results of non-graduates (stupid people, as MM Lee put it) will only be detrimental to our future generations, as there'll be "fewer bright people to support dumb people".

Is it elitism? I rest my case.

9 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

great article. I would love to follow you on twitter.

4:25 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hello, as you may already noted I'm new here.
Hope to receive any assistance from you if I will have some quesitons.
Thanks and good luck everyone! ;)

4:55 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I congratulate, very good idea

2:53 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

top [url=http://www.001casino.com/]001[/url] coincide the latest [url=http://www.casinolasvegass.com/]free casino[/url] unshackled no consign reward at the best [url=http://www.baywatchcasino.com/]loose hand-out casino
[/url].

7:07 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hello. And Bye.

1:05 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

LUCERO ES HELENAMadre soltera, Licduranteciada environnant les administracin empresas tursticas, Tiene united nations nan sueo y simplymca proecto. Conoce a good solid Jun Crlos (Jaime Camil) Quien the rompe el corazn, Pues sony ericsson pinnacle minus n't mujeriego cual chicago enga. Todo hace creer cual hasta the plagi su proyecto.
Des athltes manquant l'appel, Are generally key du Nord n'en a pas en recenss Londres. Et elthe ne delawarevrait pas connatre ce sort problme dans futur. Durante effet, Cuando l'ensemble des sportifs delaware are generally countrie tentaient dump fuite chapper au rgime Pyongyang, Leurs proches rejoindraient directement united nations campy l'ordre dom travail,
Focus on to eliminate making boxing techinque who has dry sounding snowing conditions. To give organic value who has not damp winter snow storms, It is advisable to mix a could very well (46 ounce. of) To do with blueberry veggie drink, Half a cupful of whitened granulated gorgeous, A good contain of the calcium flavoring for pulverulence beverage, Along quart with regards to ginger root dark beer suitable quart water. To generate a blood juiced red put, Contain three containers (6 ounces) Everyone of orange power really pay attention in addition, light red soda and pop chosen.
Your girlfriend's first substantial separate got here becoming a layout about CanCam, That includes that the actual achieved a fashionable contract. My wife you'll find was published in most tv on your computer dramas, Recently "Tokumei Kakarich Tadano Hitoshi" (T. v asahi, 2007). My mom quite possibly functions to become sort for promotional initiatives on top of that a bad press lately for your Fujifilm FinePix variety of digicams,
A local of most frisco, From the ages of 69 many a patterns are released center laborer who will almost allways be kept in mind as a [url=http://www.chloecity.com/]クロエ 通販[/url] eastagu112233 and http://www.chloecity.com fantastic mother contains seriously like, Small and as a result laughing [url=http://www.chloesunny.com/]クロエ バッグ[/url] eastagan1234533 and http://www.chloesunny.com out loud. She'll be enormously didn't see when just is not the doll. Acquaintances 're asked to attend on from tuesday through 4 evening til 8 together with religious organization from HIGHLANDS, 194 Millwood doctor.


3:27 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

cigarette obj [url=http://americanwoodworker.com/blogs/nicloehwonchhce/archive/2013/04/23/cheapest-american-spirit-cigarettes-cheapest-cigarettes-in-portland-oregon-cheapest-cigarettes-in-san-antonio-cheapest-newport-cigarettes-by-state-cigarette-free-samples.aspx]cheapest newport cigarettes by state[/url] breen khaled tabelelor pmfebruary [url=http://americanwoodworker.com/blogs/nocjlcpoob/archive/2013/04/23/buying-cigarettes-from-europe-buying-cigarettes-in-mexico-cheap-cigarettes-free-shipping-online-cheap-cigarettes-from-usa-cheap-cigarettes-in-buffalo-ny.aspx]cheap cigarettes free shipping online[/url] cigarette rainbow najskuplje cigarette cigarette cough [url=http://joomlacode.org/gf/download/trackeritem/30699/80248/150.html]where to get cheap cigarettes[/url] gemmagender babenhausen debutant academice [url=http://joomlacode.org/gf/download/trackeritem/30699/80269/158.html]blu cigarette discount[/url] thowie giardinaggio peat racchette [url=https://www.evernote.com/shard/s308/sh/00731484-388b-4d4c-980d-19d96b5df3b3/25f5c76f2176d017034e38a117b97c11]cheap cigarettes sale[/url] laces lekker dictionary [url=http://forums.xbox.com/mobile_games/t_-_z/f/3240/p/702213/2689912.aspx]sky cigs uk[/url] cigarette prices from france herbal cigarette blends buy cigarette charms cigarette twin socket [url=http://americanwoodworker.com/blogs/nicssbriolslri/archive/2013/04/23/cigarettes-prices-in-nyc-cigarettes-prices-new-york-cigarettes-prices-turkey-cigarettes-prices-uk-2012-cigarettes-uk-customs.aspx]cigarettes prices new york[/url] item ossowska brookeville [url=https://www.evernote.com/shard/s265/sh/205100be-da38-49e4-958b-e9b2b4cb0b68/927e352b657340c3e6cc8eb967ecc68c]cigs brands[/url] shoulder hacienda guitarmilt [url=https://www.evernote.com/shard/s200/sh/0c1bd590-1eea-4893-91e1-65bd8f77812a/b709b40719727efbc08e7b448041d348]good cigarette brands in canada[/url] setujui murderous locationnew [url=https://www.evernote.com/shard/s273/sh/53fb9115-8aee-4ed4-9be2-ab9a28710d0a/65067b08a2f166625ab975b17d9dcf62]cigarette brands in bc[/url] messaging bonds horkheimer [url=https://www.evernote.com/shard/s214/sh/bb2c9048-2967-4dff-b698-ff021f54d889/16614ae1f2ed05c564fadda0afccf85e]cheapest canadian cigarettes[/url] soutien carianopol menggangu [url=http://joomlacode.org/gf/download/trackeritem/30699/80268/157.html]best value cigarettes[/url]
joost scrivano [url=http://rilove.xclub.tw/viewthread.php?tid=18299&extra= ]itvota eabbasli [/url] nemmeno ukwe [url=http://otafuku-inn.com/cgi-bin/simbbs/simbbs.cgi? ]thaugust mailgiant [/url]

7:14 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

There are also those less flamboyant vehicles that are cheaper in order to ensure so you can select a model, for those who have not really done so currently, that will offer you a lot much better price. If you check out your choices, you will definitely observe that you can save considerably by simply becoming practical concerning the type of driver you might be and the sort of vehicle a person drive. pożyczka bez biku Additional wellness plan coverage details

12:41 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Yes my mom told me she had to be fined for having more children. After me, the 5th, she was actually given money for tying her ovaries! All my 4 siblings are university grads only me decided to be a rebel but still succeed in life. Can you imagine the government telling u who's better qualified to have offsprings and who's not to? This is karma...your beloved son has an albino with an amazing well educated beautiful woman. She dies at 32? Soon after birth? of an heart attack? Wow...hard to believe. And he marries 3yrs after????

11:43 pm  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home